Fallout, Resignation, and Community Response

Despite the apology, pressure mounted as the story gained traction online. Critics felt the city leadership had hoped the issue would blow over, but the viral attention made inaction impossible.

On September 23, Montoya formally resigned, stating: “In various capacities, I have served this community since 2008, and I am ready to pursue other interests. Effective immediately, I am resigning as council member for Ward 3. Thank you, Ward 3. It’s been an honor to serve.” Applause followed her announcement.

The incident has sparked wider discussions in Norman about the online conduct of public officials. Residents urged the adoption of a formal code of conduct, with Paul Wilson noting, “Stop being the only city in the metro that doesn’t have one.” Others criticized Mayor Stephen Tyler Holman for remaining silent until the controversy attracted national attention.

Montoya’s resignation leaves the Ward 3 seat vacant, with applications now open for candidates to fill the position, due by early October. For the city, the saga is more than one councilwoman’s misstep — it has become a conversation about accountability, standards for online behavior, and expectations for local leaders.